Minister Javier Silvania Speech Chata
Minister Javier Silvania
Speech Chata – 28 November 2024
Good morning, ladies and gentlemen,
First, I would like to thank CHATA for the invitation to speak with you today. It is a privilege to share insights into the projects we’ve been working on, as well as the key developments and initiatives that are helping to shape the future of our tourism sector.
While fostering growth remains a top priority, we are equally committed to ensuring fairness, compliance, and sustainability across the sector. We recognize that laws alone are not enough—they are merely words on paper without the proper tools for supervision and enforcement. That’s why we are dedicated to implementing robust monitoring and enforcement mechanisms to ensure our regulations drive meaningful change.
We are paving the way for a tourism industry that is not only competitive and profitable but also sustainable and respectful of our unique natural resources. Let’s delve into the details and explore the steps we’re taking towards creating a level playing field within our tourism sector.
In collaboration with CHATA and CASHA, the Ministry of Finance has been working to create a level playing field within the tourism sector. What began as a small initiative to address the illegal rental accommodations for tourists, has since evolved into a much larger and more impactful project.
The primary objective of this project was to identify illegal rentals of accommodations on the island, enabling the tax authorities to include these renters in their database. This ensures that everyone pays the required sales tax, fostering fairness across the tourism industry. Illegal renters gain an unfair advantage by avoiding sales tax, allowing them to charge lower prices for their accommodations. This creates an imbalance, putting compliant taxpayers at a disadvantage, as their prices are likely higher due to the added tax.
As mentioned, this project expanded significantly over time. Initially focused on real estate, it soon grew to address tax avoidance across the entire tourism sector. The tax authorities broadened their efforts to include issues such as the (i) illegal rental of yachts and unauthorized boat trips, (ii) unregistered tours and excursions, (iii) and illegal dive shops. All of these became integral parts of the project, aiming to ensure fairness and compliance across the sector and thus creating a level playing field in the tourism sector.
Building on this foundation, let’s now take a closer look at how we’ve expanded our efforts to tackle illegal rentals, unregistered tours and excursions and Illegal dive shops to promote compliance across the broader tourism sector.
Illegal rental of yachts and unauthorized boat trips
In collaboration with the Coast Guard, the tax authorities conduct on-site observations, known as WTPs. These observations provide valuable insights, helping the tax authorities identify the taxpayers involved in this project. When vessels are consistently found—at least three times—engaged in commercial activities, they are designated as part of the project.
Unregistered tours and excursions
The tax authorities collected information from third parties offering tourism activities at hotels and selling tickets through ticket shops. They compared the transactions from online ticket shops with the tax identification numbers of registered taxpayers. This process revealed who is already known to the tax authorities and whether event organizers are meeting their tax obligations. The data obtained from these online ticket shops will play a key role in assessing compliance.
Illegal dive shops
The tax authorities used the internet as a tool to identify dive schools and dive shops. In 2023, the Dive Task Force took the initiative to address challenges within the sector and work towards implementing structured regulations and legislation. The goal was to ensure the growth and sustainability of the tourism industry, particularly dive schools, while preserving Curaçao’s reputation as a premier diving destination. These efforts are also expected to contribute to increased tax revenues over time. While addressing these illegal activities, we recognized the need for more structured regulations in another crucial sector: diving.
As a result, I instituted a workgroup that aims to develop, review, and enforce regulations and standards related to diving activities.
I will elaborate on the work of this workgroup shortly but first, allow me to give you a sneak peek into the statistics and results of the illegal rental project:
This graph shows the tax and social premiums paid in the months of January through October for the years 2017 through 2024 with regard to the illegal rental project.
Tax revenues for the months of January through October of Fiscal year 2024 are generally significantly higher than those for the same period in the previous years.
As promised, Let’s now delve into the details workgroup that aims to develop, review, and enforce regulations and standards related to diving activities better known as the Dive Regulation Workgroup.
The Dive Regulation Workgroup is a collaborative body dedicated to developing, reviewing, and enforcing regulations and standards for diving activities. Key stakeholders in this workgroup include the Ministry of Health, Environment and Nature, the Undersea & Dive Medical Expertise Group, and CHATA.
One of the primary action points of this workgroup is to establish a regulatory body responsible for overseeing diving activities, ensuring compliance, and enforcing regulations. Additionally, existing legislation, ordinances, and laws will be reviewed and updated as needed. These updates will address the scope of the regulations, permissible activities, and enforcement mechanisms, as well as define the geographical and operational jurisdiction of the regulations.
Under the new and improved regulations, dive operators and schools will be required to obtain a business license and special permits that confirm compliance with safety, environmental, and operational standards. Furthermore, all dive instructors, guides and personnel will be required to hold recognized certifications from accredited organizations (e.g., PADI, NAUI, SSI) and to be registered with the local regulatory body. The dive operators and schools will also be required to implement health and fitness regulations to ensure that divers meet medical standards appropriate for their level of activity and dive type.
The new legislation will also include minimum safety and operational standards, for example equipment standards, emergency protocols and safety briefings before dives. These standards will also include maximum depth limits, decompression practices, and use of dive computers.
While we aim to grow our tourism sector, we must also prioritize protecting our marine ecosystem. To this end, the workgroup will develop specific regulations to prevent damage to coral reefs, safeguard endangered species, and limit the number of divers in sensitive areas. Additionally, we will establish strict rules for waste management, including prohibiting littering and regulating the discharge of pollutants from dive boats.
While regulations are essential, laws are merely written words without the proper tools for supervision and enforcement. That’s why this workgroup establish the mechanisms necessary to monitor and effectively enforce compliance with the applicable laws and regulations. The monitoring and supervision mechanisms may include for instance regular inspections and audits of dive schools, boats, and equipment. Furthermore, there will be penalties for violations of the legislation. These penalties will be ranging from fines and suspension of licenses to criminal charges in severe cases.
We aim to align our local laws and regulations with internationally recognized standards and best practices, such as those established by the World Recreational Scuba Training Council (WRSTC) and the International Maritime Organization (IMO).
In summary, our focus in the coming period will be to foster the growth and integrity of the diving industry while prioritizing safety and environmental protection.
Just as we’re ensuring the diving industry operates sustainably, we’re also looking at sustainable ways to fund and support our tourism sector through initiatives like the introduction of a visitor entry fee.
The rise of platforms like Airbnb, VRBO, and Booking.com within the tourism industry addressed a wide range of tourist needs while harnessing technological advancements. These platforms provided homeowners and apartment owners with an alternative means to earn and save money, especially during times of global economic challenges. The rise of these platforms brought challenges for the government as well as traditional accommodation providers such as hotels. As you all know, the short term rental of accommodations in Curacao is currently subject to 7% sales tax, also known as the room tax. The funds collected from the room tax were utilized in part to indirectly finance the Curaçao Tourist Board (CTB).
As I already mentioned, the Ministry of Finance, in collaboration with CHATA and CASHA, has been working to create a level playing field within the tourism sector. One of the main issues, is the issue mentioned above; namely the illegal rental of accommodations. This puts the traditional accommodation providers and other compliant taxpayers at a disadvantage, as their prices are likely higher due to the room tax.
Although, up till now we have focused out efforts in identifying these non-compliant companies, we do feel that there is room for elimination of the causes of non-compliance.
According to a report, prepared by EY, the revenue generation from the room tax has not kept pace with the increased room rates and the growth in tourist arrivals in Curacao. In response to the perceived lagging of the tax revenue, despite the surge in tourism, a new (tax) framework is being considered. This new (tax) framework seeks to accomplish the following:
1. ensure equitable tax contributions from all short-term rental properties,
2. streamline the tax process for ease of compliance, and
3. guarantee that (tax) income reflects the rising tourist numbers.
In light hereof, the ministry of finance, in collaboration with the Curacao Tourist Board is exploring alternative solutions for generating revenue that aligns with the growth of our tourism sector.
To this end, in collaboration with the Curacao Tour Board, we intend to introduce a so-called sustainability fee, which will be payable before or upon entry into our island.
Currently, accommodations act as intermediaries between the taxpayer—the tourist—and the tax authorities, which presents challenges in collecting the taxes owed. Despite the ongoing efforts and manpower of the tax authorities to address these issues, not every taxpayer is successfully identified. To tackle this, we are considering shifting the payment of taxes from accommodations to the tourist directly upon entry. This approach could provide a viable solution to the tax compliance challenges we are facing today. Our sister islands Bonaire and Aruba, have already successfully implemented the levy of such fees.
The current challenges lie in determining the appropriate fee amount, deciding how the fee will be collected, and allocating the revenues. This includes identifying what portion will go to the Tourism Board and what portion will be used by the government for essential services such as maintaining roads, beaches, and other infrastructure. Additionally, the fee should be perceived as ‘fair’ by tourists, given the price sensitivity of Curaçao as a travel destination.
As with most important matters, I have established a dedicated working group to address the current challenges and prepare the necessary legislation. This group includes representatives from the Curaçao Tourist Board, the private sector, and the Ministry of Finance.
Beyond regulations and taxes, there are other issues that impact the quality of our tourism experience, like the overpopulation of stray animals on our island.
The overpopulation of stray dogs and cats is a significant issue in Curaçao. Many of these animals are either abandoned or run away, creating undesirable situations where stray animals are commonly seen throughout the island—often malnourished and scavenging by the roadside. These animals frequently become feral and fall into poor health, suffering from diseases such as scabies, distemper, and heartworm. They can cause various nuisances, such as knocking over garbage cans, disturbing joggers, and even posing risks to traffic and public health. Moreover, their uncontrolled reproduction worsens the problem over time. In suburban areas, stray dogs have been known to attack and kill sheep and goats, further highlighting the severity of this issue.
The Curaçao Tourist Board’s primary role is to promote the island as a premier tourist destination. However, they are often confronted with messages and reviews from concerned tourists about the overwhelming number of stray animals, which can negatively impact the island’s image.
Addressing this issue requires a structured plan of action, which includes:
1. Educating the public about applicable legislation.
2. Implementing a system for identifying and registering animals in a centralized database.
3. Launching a sterilization program to reduce the stray animal population.
4. Monitoring compliance with animal welfare laws.
It is important to note that, under the National Animal Welfare Ordinance, all dogs must be microchipped by January 1, 2025. This is a vital step toward better animal control and ensuring a sustainable solution to this ongoing challenge.
Accountability is key to success, and effective inspections form the foundation of our approach to ensure compliance and fairness.
Following an incident involving a hygiene inspection at a restaurant, the Inspectorate of Public Health has introduced significant updates to its policies and procedures, aimed at enhancing the effectiveness of inspections and ensuring public health standards are upheld.
The new policy is built on a systematic approach, addressing the entire supply chain—from importers to wholesalers, smaller retail outlets, and the hospitality sector.
Under the new policy, restaurants will no longer face closures at night. Instead, restaurant owners are now required to establish internal control systems such as appointing a designated representative responsible for ensuring compliance with hygiene standards. These representatives must regularly report to the Inspectorate of Public Health to confirm adherence to the regulations. Additionally, the Ministry of Health retains the right to conduct unannounced spot checks to assess whether all hygiene criteria, as established by the ministry, are being met. This approach aims to maintain high standards while minimizing disruptions to restaurant operations.
By appointing internal controllers or quality managers, establishments can take a more proactive role in maintaining compliance. The aim is to reduce deviations detected during external inspections by empowering businesses to self-regulate effectively. Routine inspections will continue, and complaint-based inspections will be phased out as internal monitoring improves.
With the implementation of a structured approach for inspections, each company will receive at least two routine visits annually. During these visits, inspectors will assess inventory, products offered for sale, and related administration.
The prioritization is as follows:
1. Importers and wholesalers followed by
2. Supermarkets and smaller establishments, and then
3. the hospitality sector.
Inspections will always involve two inspectors, and the schedule will not be shared in advance to maintain the integrity of the process.
To support these changes, hygiene certificates for food and beverage personnel will have an extended validity period. These updated policies and enhanced procedures have officially taken effect on April 1, 2024.
As you can see, our efforts span a wide range of issues, all aimed at fostering a thriving, balanced, and sustainable tourism industry.

639114718427035"
639114718427035"

