Cft: “Meer voortgang nodig bij lang uitstaande zaken en ontwerpbegroting 2020”
Cft: “Mas progreso ta nesesario den asuntunan ku pa basta tempu ta pendiente i tambe ku proyekto di presupuesto 2020”
Philipsburg – Kolegio di supervishon finansiero (Cft) ta ripití un biaha mas ku Sint Maarten mester realisá mas progreso ku algun asuntu ku ta pendiente, manera reforma di pension, redukshon di gastunan di kuido médiko i reforma di servisio di impuesto. Apesar di e situashon polítiko aktual, e Kolegio ta enfatisá serka Sint Maarten pa ketu bai hasi tur loke ta posibel pa dal e pasonan nesesario i kuminsá e aña nobo ku un presupuesto aprobá.
Proyekto di presupuesto 2020 i ehekushon 2019
E proyekto di presupuesto 2020 ainda ta reflehá un défisit di 24 mion florin. Pa e motibu aki, a base di artíkulo 25 di e lei di konsenso di Reino tokante di supervishon finansiero, aprobashon di Konseho di Minister di Reino ta rekerí. E artíkulo en kuestion ta permití, bou di sirkunstansha partikular manera e konsekuensia di orkannan Irma i Maria, pa e pais por desviá for di e regla pa un presupuesto balansá. Cft ta rekomendá pa redusí e gastunan di 2020 te un nivel mas realístiko. Tambe Cft ta konsehá Sint Maarten pa kuminsá e aña presupuestario ku un presupuesto aprobá.
Relashoná ku ehekushon di presupuesto 2019, Sint Maarten ta premirá ku e lo finalisá e aña ku un défisit di 41 mion florin, loke ta mas abou ku e montante ku anteriormente a keda presupuestá (71 mion florin). Pa loke ta trata e posishon di likides, e di dos reportahe di kuartal 2019 ta indiká un montante di 84,8 mion florin na likides. Pa por bini na remarke pa sosten di likides, Sint Maarten mester kumpli tambe ku algun kondishon ku ainda e no a kumpli kuné, manera subida di e edat di penshon di empleadonan públiko di 62 pa 65, inkluso e transishon di un sistema di penshon basá riba e último suèldo pa un sistema basá riba un suèldo medio, i redukshon di salarionan di miembronan di Parlamento.
Cft a komprondé tambe ku e akuerdonan di finansiamento ku e fondo di trust i EIB pa rekonstrukshon di aeropuerto ainda no ta firmá i e ta enfatisá un biaha mas e importansia di e rekonstrukshon di e aeropuerto pa por sigurá i sigui mehorá e perspektiva ekonómiko di e pais.
Asuntunan remarkabel
Cft ta ferwagt ku den e temporada benidero Sint Maarten lo mester yega e nivel di presupuesto di 2016, esta promé ku orkan Irma, i konsekuentemente Sint Maarten mester por kumpli ku e lei di konsenso di Reino tokante supervishon finansiero. Sinembargo, pa por realisá tur esaki, mester atendé mas lihé posibel ku un kantidat di asuntu ku ta habrí ainda. Na kabes di e lista aki ta pará e reforma planeá di e servisio di impuesto. E plan aki aprel último a keda aprobá pa Konseho di Minister, pero su ehekushon ainda mester kuminsá. Ta spera ku e reforma tan antisipá aki lo kontribuí na un kresementu struktural di e entradanan di Gobièrnu. E entradanan adishonal aki entre otro lo hasi posibel pa kompensá e défisitnan aktual i esnan bieu, i redusí e atraso grandi di e pagonan kuantioso. Te ainda Sint Maarten a kumpli ku algun pago i den e kuadro aki resientemente e pais a sera akuerdo ku Telem i SZV.
Otro asuntunan pendiente ta mehora di e maneho finansiero i reforma di e sistema di penshon i e sistema di kuido. Cft ta pidi atenshon spesial pa e reforma di e sistema di penshon i e sistema di kuido, mirando e konsekuensianan negativo ku esaki por trese kuné, si nan no keda manehá adekuadamente. E proyekto di lei pa e revishon di e penshon di amtenar a keda entregá na òktober 2018 na Parlamento, pero ainda e no a keda akordá. Ainda mester presentá e subida di edat di penshon di 62 pa 65 aña na Parlamento.
E falta aktual di medionan finansiero a keda menshoná komo un di e motibunan prinsipal dikon e plan di mehora di e maneho finansiero ainda no ta ehekutá. Esaki por trese retraso kuné pa e aña 2021 ku ta akordá komo e aña den kua Sint Maarten lo mester risibí un deklarashon aprobatorio di akountent relashoná ku e aña ei. Cft ta konsehá Sint Maarten pa e hasi tur su esfuerso pa e aselerá ehekushon di e plan. Pa loke ta trata kuentanan anual di añanan anterior, e kuenta anual 2016 no a risibí un opinion positivo di e akountent, ni di Kontrolaria General di Sint Maarten. Sint Maarten ta intenshoná pa kontratá asistensia tékniko pa traha kuentanan anual 2017 i 2018, mirando ku esaki ainda no a tuma lugá. Tambe Parlamento ainda mester aprobá e kuentanan anual di 2015 i 2016.
Kolegio di supervishon finansiero Kòrsou i Sint Maarten a bishitá Sint Maarten di 28 pa 30 di òktober i a hiba kòmbersashon ku Gobernador, Minister di Finansa, Konseho di Minister, komishon finansiero di Parlamento, e miembro di e Grupo Nashonal di Guia pa Rekuperashon di Sint Maarten, Komishon di Progreso Sint Maarten i Konseho di Mantenshon di Lei.
Cft: “Meer voortgang nodig bij lang uitstaande zaken en ontwerpbegroting 2020”
Philipsburg – Het College financieel toezicht (Cft) herhaalt nogmaals dat Sint Maarten meer voortgang moet boeken bij een aantal openstaande zaken, zoals de pensioenhervormingen, de verlaging van de zorgkosten en de hervorming van de belastingdienst. Ondanks de huidige politieke situatie dringt het College er bij Sint Maarten nog steeds op aan alles te doen om de nodige stappen te zetten en het begrotingsjaar 2020 te starten met een goedgekeurde begroting.
Ontwerpbegroting 2020 en uitvoering 2019
De ontwerpbegroting 2020 vertoont nog steeds een tekort van 24 miljoen gulden. Goedkeuring van de Rijksministerraad is daarom vereist op basis van artikel 25 van de consensusrijkswet betreffende financieel toezicht. Dit artikel staat het land onder bijzondere omstandigheden zoals de nasleep van orkanen Irma en Maria toe af te wijken van de regel voor begrotings evenwicht. Het Cft beveelt aan om de uitgaven van 2020 terug te brengen tot een realistischer niveau. Ook raadt het Cft Sint Maarten aan het begrotingsjaar 2020 te beginnen met een goedgekeurde begroting.
Met betrekking tot de uitvoering van de begroting 2019 verwacht Sint Maarten het jaar te eindigen met een tekort van 41 miljoen gulden, wat lager uitvalt dan begroot (71 miljoen gulden). Wat de liquiditeitspositie betreft, toont het tweede kwartaalrapportage 2019 een bedrag van 84,8 miljoen gulden aan liquiditeit. Om in aanmerking te komen voor liquiditeitssteun, moet Sint Maarten ook voldoen aan bepaalde voorwaarden waar het nog niet aan heeft voldaan, zoals de verhoging van de pensioengerechtigde leeftijd van de ambtenaren van 62 naar 65, met inbegrip van de overgang van een eindloon pensioenstelsel naar een middelloon pensioenstelsel en de verlaging van de salarissen van de leden van het Parlement.
Het Cft heeft ook begrepen dat de financieringsovereenkomsten met het trustfonds en de EIB voor heropbouw van de luchthaven nog niet zijn ondertekend en benadrukt nogmaals het belang van het herstel van de luchthaven voor het veiligstellen en verder verbeteren van de economische vooruitzichten van het land.
Opmerkelijke zaken
Het Cft verwacht dat Sint Maarten in de nabije toekomst het pre-Irma begrotingsniveau van 2016 moet hebben bereikt en daarom in staat zou moeten zijn om te voldoen aan de consensusrijkswet betreffende financieel toezicht. Om dit te bereiken, moet echter een aantal reeds lang openstaande zaken zo snel mogelijk worden aangepakt. Bovenaan deze lijst staat de geplande hervorming van de belastingdienst. Dit plan is afgelopen april goedgekeurd door de Raad van Ministers, maar de uitvoering ervan moet nog van start gaan. Verwacht wordt dat deze langverwachte hervorming zal bijdragen tot een structurele groei van de overheidsinkomsten. Deze extra inkomsten zullen onder andere Sint Maarten in staat stellen om huidige en oude tekorten te compenseren en de aanzienlijke achterstallige betalingen te verlagen. Tot nu toe heeft Sint Maarten enkele betalingen voldaan en in dit kader onlangs ook overeenkomsten gesloten met Telem en SZV.
Andere openstaande kwesties zijn de verbetering van het financieel beheer en de hervorming van het pensioen- en gezondheidszorgstelsel. Het Cft vraagt speciale aandacht voor de hervorming van het pensioen- en gezondheidszorgstelsel, gezien de nadelige gevolgen die dit voor de overheidsbegroting kan hebben, indien deze onvoldoende worden beheerd. De ontwerpwetgeving voor de herziening van het ambtenarenpensioen is in oktober 2018 bij het Parlement ingediend, maar is nog niet goedgekeurd. De verhoging van de AOV-leeftijd van 62 naar 65 moet nog aan het Parlement worden voorgelegd.
Het huidige gebrek aan middelen is genoemd als de belangrijkste reden waarom het verbeterplan voor financieel beheer nog niet is uitgevoerd. Dit kan vertraging veroorzaken voor het overeengekomen jaar 2021 waarin Sint Maarten een goedkeurende accountantsverklaring met betrekking tot de jaarrekening van dat jaar zou moeten ontvangen. Het Cft adviseert Sint Maarten zich in te spannen om de uitvoering van het plan te bespoedigen. Wat oudere jaarrekeningen betreft, heeft de jaarrekening 2016 geen positief oordeel van de accountant noch de Algemene Rekenkamer van Sint Maarten ontvangen. Sint Maarten is van plan technische bijstand in te huren om de jaarrekeningen 2017 en 2018 op te stellen, aangezien dit nog steeds niet heeft plaatsgevonden. Ook moeten de jaarrekeningen van 2015 en 2016 nog worden goedgekeurd door het Parlement.
Het College financieel toezicht Curaçao en Sint Maarten heeft van 28 tot 30 oktober een bezoek gebracht aan Sint Maarten en besprekingen gevoerd met de Gouverneur, de Minister van Financiën, de Raad van Ministers, de financiële commissie van het Parlement, het lid van de Nationale Stuurgroep voor Herstel van Sint Maarten, het Nationaal Programmabureau en de Voortgangscommissie en de Raad voor de Rechtshandhaving.
Speaker’s notes of the Cft chairman
Press conference Sint Maarten
October 30th, 2019
Good morning members of the press,
Thank you for being here today.
As per usual, we have had several meetings on the island during our visit. On Monday we have met with the Governor and with the steering committee and the Program Bureau for national recovery regarding the progress on the recovery efforts. Yesterday, we sat down with the minister of finance, the council of ministers and the parliamentary committee of finance. This morning we, as Cft, met with the Progress Committee Sint Maarten with respect to the police force and the detention center and Law Enforcement Council.
The board also visited Sint Eustatius on Monday. Given that the temporary law of task neglect is in place, the Cft has no formal role regarding Sint Eustatius. Nevertheless, we were asked to stay informed about the budget cycle and the financial management.
Before highlighting some of the topics discussed with respect to Sint Maarten I would like to start by giving some perspective on the function of the Cft and its context as there is a public debate on this.
The consensus Kingdom Law on financial supervision, the so called Rft, was adopted as part of agreements regarding the new countries Curaçao and Sint Maarten. The Netherlands also agreed to take over 70% of the outstanding debt of the former Dutch Antilles for the amount of 3.4 billion guilders, in order to give the countries a healthy starting position. The board of financial supervision, the Cft, was founded as a temporary entity to prevent that the countries would again find themselves with an unsustainable debt position. Importantly, also as part of this arrangement a low Dutch interest rate, currently zero, applies for the outstanding debt and new loans for capital investments. This interest is significantly lower than the interest rate in other Caribbean small countries, of at least 5 percent.
While for most countries in the Caribbean the interest payments can reach 20 percent or more of the income level of the public sector, for Sint Maarten these are currently at about 2 percent of income. Importantly, while other countries have to spend public money on interest, Sint Maarten can use this to provide better services for the public such as security or education.
The Cft has a monitoring and signaling role and checks whether the budgets meet the standards and norms in the Rft. The Cft can provide solicited and unsolicited advice to the governments and the Kingdom council of Ministers. As the Cft we continuously provide recommendations to Sint Maarten, through the minister of finance, to avoid an unsustainable rise in the debt levels, while also taking into account measures that are important for the general public.
As mentioned at the start of this press briefing, we have had several meetings during this visit to Sint Maarten. I would like to use this opportunity to highlight some of the topics discussed thus far.
- The 2019 performance
First, we have noticed a good recovery of the economy, this reflects the resilience of the people of Sint Maarten. Real economic growth will be above three percent in 2019 and realized tax revenues will be higher than forecasted in the budget.
The second quarterly report for 2019 shows a deficit of 0.8 million guilders up until June. Sint Maarten expects to end 2019 with a much smaller deficit of approximately 40 million than the budgeted deficit of 71 million guilders. The minister of finance forecasts for 2019 an income of 435 million guilders.
However, the income realized by Sint Maarten could be much higher if the increase in tax compliance as a result of restructuring the tax administration is achieved. There is room for government revenue to grow, once the highly necessary restructuring efforts have been put into place. This increase in income is much needed in order to implement policy objectives and to compensate current and historical deficits.
Cost-saving measures from the 2019 budget as the reform of the civil servant pension scheme and the employee contributions to the healthcare fund by civil servants have not yet been implemented. The reform of the civil servant pension scheme consists of raising the pension age from 62 to 65 and changing the scheme based on a final salary to a scheme based on average salary. This is important for the sustainability of public finance. We know that this law is already a year on the table of the parliament, and we urged the parliament to pass it.
- Financial management and the tax authority
Sint Maarten’s financial management is in serious need of improvement. In April of this year, the Council of Ministers approved both the Financial Management improvement plan and the plan to improve the tax authority. The implementation of these projects has been linked to DPO funding via the World Bank and other funding. The DPO funds will be released once Sint Maarten has met certain conditions in 2019 and 2020.
- Financial statements
We have noticed further delays in the finalization of past yearly reporting periods. Sint Maarten has a backlog with respect to its reporting responsibilities, which is a direct symptom of the current state of financial management. The latest approved financial statements are from 2014. We have also spoken to parliament about their responsibilities with respect to the financial statements.
- The draft budget 2020
The minister of Finance of Sint Maarten submitted the 2020 draft budget to the Cft on September 27th. The presented deficit for 2020 is estimated at 24 million guilders. On October 1st, the Cft advised on the draft budget on the basis of the Rft. The draft budget is also based on economic growth of almost three percent in 2020. Importantly, in this respect is a full recovery of the airport.
The Cft understood that the finance agreements for the recovery of the Airport are not signed yet and emphasizes the importance of the recovery of the airport for the country’s economic prospects.
Given the deficit in the 2020 budget, Sint Maarten will also need to formally request, on the grounds of article 25 of the Rft, to deviate from the standards set in article 15 of the Rft. This request has already been sent by the Minister of Finance to the Kingdom Council. It is important to bear in mind that the budget for 2020 has to be adopted by parliament before the 15th of December.
- The 2015 targeted Instruction
Sint Maarten realized deficits in 2014 and 2015, which led to an instruction by the Kingdom Council of Ministers. In November of last year Sint Maarten reported to the Kingdom Council on its progress regarding the execution of instruction given to Sint Maarten in 2015, on which report the Cft issued an advice in December of last year. The Cft advised to keep the instruction enforced by extending the deadlines. The revised instruction has not yet been formalized. Regarding the progress of the items in the instruction, we can state the following:
Deficit compensation
Deficit compensation will only be possible with surpluses that are expected by Sint Maarten starting fiscal year 2021. In order to comply with deficit compensation from the past, also prior to Irma, Sint Maarten should have a surplus for many years. Actually, Sint Maarten had deficits since 2010, a result of the misalignment of expenditures to income. It is a comprehensive task to turn the cycle of deficits into structural surpluses in the coming years.
Payment arrears
In accordance with the recommendations by the Cft, Sint Maarten finalized agreements for debt settlement with the government entities GEBE and Telem. A letter of intent has been drawn up and signed between the minister of Finance and the SZV.
In addition, the payment arrears have been steadily decreasing and are at 139 million guilders per the end of June. It is of utmost importance that further action is taken to ensure a continued decrease in the payment arrears.
Sustainable old age pension
In order to ensure a sustainable system, government has proposed to increase the AOV age from 62 to 65 years by 2020. The Cft advised for this change in order to increase the financial sustainability of the fund, managed by SZV. Sint Maarten is expected to take the necessary steps in order to meet this date. The legislation for the increase of the AOV age has yet to been sent to parliament.
Affordable and sustainable healthcare
Sint Maarten indicated in its reaction on the draft revised instruction that the implementation of the General Health Insurance as per January 2020 is no longer feasible but the need for affordable and sustainable healthcare is still there.
The need for cost cutting measures for healthcare is partially highlighted through the overall negative results of the healthcare funds managed by the SZV. The Cft has understood that progress is being made with some short term measures:
- reducing the cost of medicine and
- lowering the number and costs of medical referrals abroad
It is important to broaden the premium base by raising the maximum income under which people pay healthcare premium.
In summary, with the exception of repayment agreements made to further decrease payment arrears and some short-term cost saving measures relating to healthcare, there has been too little progress on the larger items in the instruction.
- Liquidity
The latest presented monthly report for 2019 shows that Sint Maarten had about 61 million guilders in liquidity as per the end of august. With the upcoming months this will lead to a serious deterioration of the liquidity position.
Liquidity support for 2019 will only be received when Sint Maarten complies with a number of conditions imposed by the Kingdom Council of Ministers. The conditions are the decrease of the parliamentary salaries with 10% and the passing of the civil servant pension reform as per January 1st, 2020. So, also from this perspective there is need for the parliament to finalize it.
- In conclusion
To conclude, in the period following our visit last June we have noted progress in some areas as well as stagnation in others. While the 2019 budget has finally been adopted and the 2020 budget was drafted, the budget needs to be adopted by December 15th.
I also want to emphasize that several high priority projects, such as the reform of the tax administration, still need to reach execution. Regardless of the factors that may have contributed to delays in projects, it is of the utmost importance to obtain results that are in the best interest of Sint Maarten.
Thank you for your attention.
